Thread: Pisa for jenkins-would you make that deal?
View Single Post
  #1 (permalink)  
Old -09-04-2007
general counsel's Avatar
general counsel
Status: Online
Pro Bowl Ram
  
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: atlanta, georgia
Age: 46
Posts: 3,656
Rep Power: 30
general counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond reputegeneral counsel has a reputation beyond repute
Pisa for jenkins-would you make that deal?
slightly different take on the situation. Would you trade pisa straight up for jenkins. I dont know how i come out on this, but consider this. Pisa hardly qualifies as a model of health. He has been banged up and he missed games last year. He is as tough as they come, but i believe he is still only average at best in pass coverage and with the abuse his body has taken, you could argue that he is an increasing health risk. With his new contract, he is no longer dirt cheap either.


Jenkins has risks and baggage for sure, he also has a lot more upside than pisa.

I dont know if i would do this deal,, but i think i would rather have pisa than a third round pick so i guess that means that i would trade a #3 for jenkins. I would certainly throw in butler.

I am often at my best when i am negotiating with myself.

ramming speed to all

general counsel
__________________

Reply With Quote