Okay, on another forum there was quite a spirited debate about Bulger's longevity and prospects for continuing as the Rams' QB. I think the consensus was that for better or worse (depending on your perspective) Mark is our guy. Some have speculated that he is capable of being a top five QB in the NFL. So be it. But with that in mind, I invite you to name the top 8 (25%) the QBs in the NFL not named Mark Bulger. Use whatever criteria you wish to rate them but so state what that criteria is so we understand your perspective. Put them in order from #1 best to 8th best.
For my rankings I used a lot of "feel" in my choices. While performance was important, I did not crunch statistics for any analysis. Some choices will be obvious to you but an overarching judgment I made for my choices was their field generalship, huddle presence and demonstrated enthusiasm for the game and on field success (Ws and Ls).
- Tom Brady
- Peyton Manning
- Ben Roethlesberger
- Matt Hasselbeck
- Drew Brees
- Carson Palmer
- Donovan McNabb
- David Girard
Honorable mention: Philip Rivers