[moklerman]

These are my "no-brainers"(in no particular order):
Manning
Brady
Palmer
Roethlisberger
Brees
Hasslebeck

These are my "if only":
McNabb
Warner
Garcia

These are my "jury's still out but I think they're top QB's":
Romo
Schaub
Garrard
Anderson

These are my "supposed to be good, but..."
Cutler
Rivers
E. Manning
Campbell

These are my "how are these guys still starters?"
Pennington
Kitna
Boller
Grossman

These are my "Kordell Stewarts(great athletes, not QB's)":
Young
Jackson
Lemon