Okay I will pick

You must score to win or your best hope is a 0 to 0 tie.

So I need offense well the quickest way to get down field is through the air. So I need a fast athletic WR but he is useless if he does not have the ball. So I need a QB that can complete a pass but no QB can complete a pass if he gets knocked on his can every time they hike him the ball. Well lets see I also need a RB that can gain positive yards and help run down the clock when we get ahead keeping the ball out of the opponents hands. But no running back can gain positive yards if he has four fat 300 pound guys looking at him like he is the last of the filet mignon steaks and no one is protecting the steak. So I would start by improving both my running game and my passing game. I would do this by selecting my own big fat guy a 6'7 320lb OL Orlando Pace.
He could help guard my steak and keep my QB off his can long enough that he could complete a pass to the WR. Sorry so long I got into this.

#1 Pick Orlando Pace.