An Excellent Example on "How Not to Build An MB!"
RN2 Ravens Message Board
A very good example of the difference between RamDez and the the rest of the people who call themselves Mods.
To shy away or not to shy away...
Atlas, near the bottom right corner of the page --such as this one, there's a "Rate This Thread" drop menu. There, Dez allows one to select from several ratings using stars.
I also think that what you're suggesting is a good idea ..."but" most of us probably shy away from specifically tagging the posts as good, lousy, excellent, etc. I suppose that would have to be left to the moderators to determine.
Enjoy your weekend, take care.