Top 8 NFL QBs not named Bulger

[keith m. klink]

K. Warner
C. Palmer
P. Manning
T. Brady
D. Brees
E. Manning
B. Rothlesberger
M. Hasselbeck

[NotVeryOriginal]

1) Manning
2) Brady
3) Romo
4) Big Ben
5) Gerrard
6) McNabb
7) Warner
8) Anderson

Judge by the impact they made to their team. Romo lead his team to a bye week, and through Gerrard Del Rio channels his Kwan. The other top 5 explain themselves. If we were to include Bulger Id put him at 6.

[moklerman]

I'm kinda confused by these lists. Is it for 2007 only? Garrard and Anderson have a LOT to prove as far as I'm concerned and they're just sitting in the Cinderella pumpkin right now.

[Ramer]

If were talking 07.

1) Manning
2) Brady
3) Romo
4) Big Ben
5) Gerrard
6) McNabb
7) Warner
8) Collins

[Chris58]

Originally Posted by moklerman

I'm kinda confused by these lists. Is it for 2007 only? Garrard and Anderson have a LOT to prove as far as I'm concerned and they're just sitting in the Cinderella pumpkin right now.

Well I just wanted ClanRamer's thoughts on who they thought the top 8 NFL QB's are today. Some of you might see a rising star who doesn't have a lot of experience but you think they are in the top 25%. Others may base it on performance over time. Some just like guys for no other reason than the number they wear, or the team they play on, or the college they went to. But in any event, I was hoping for some justification as to why they picked the ones they did.

I gave justification for my list as being 1. perceived leaders on the field and 2. performance. I included Garrard because I liked the way he has played the last 2 seasons, taking over in mid-year last year as an unknown and doing pretty well for Jax. I also heard an interview with him and was very impressed with his knowledge, communication skills and class. After that, I was a Garrard guy and that's why I picked him in my top 8. :l

[tbw2rfm4td]

Originally Posted by Ramer

If were talking 07.

1) Manning
2) Brady
3) Romo
4) Big Ben
5) Gerrard
6) McNabb
7) Warner
8) Collins

If you're talking 2007 then how is Peyton Manning ahead of Tom Brady? And Warner and Collins? Seriously?

[laram0]

Bulger had a terrible 2007 because of the musical chairs played on our O-LINE.
He will bounce back in 2008.

1. Brady
2. P. Manning
3. Palmer
4. Brees
5. Romo
6. E. Manning
7. BULGER
8. Big Ben

Next tier

Kurt Warner
Donovan McNabb
David Garrard
Derek Anderson
Matt Hasselbeck

[Tampa_Ram]

1. Alex Smith
2. Chris Simms
3. Cleo Lemon
4. Rex Grossman
5. Tevaris Jackson
6. Joey Harrington
7. J.P. Losman
8. Gus Frerotte


There you go. The Best of the best.............:\

[moklerman]

These are my "no-brainers"(in no particular order):
Manning
Brady
Palmer
Roethlisberger
Brees
Hasslebeck

These are my "if only":
McNabb
Warner
Garcia

These are my "jury's still out but I think they're top QB's":
Romo
Schaub
Garrard
Anderson

These are my "supposed to be good, but..."
Cutler
Rivers
E. Manning
Campbell

These are my "how are these guys still starters?"
Pennington
Kitna
Boller
Grossman

These are my "Kordell Stewarts(great athletes, not QB's)":
Young
Jackson
Lemon

[Ramer]

I don't think McNabb should be in the top 8. After this season Bulger will be on this list.