If it came down to these two guys who would you take?

I will start it off with RamsFan16 taking Greenway

If I had to, I'd take Sims. If that's whats left at 11, I'd be on the phone looking to trade down.

I'd probably take Greenway. Less upside than Sims but Ernie's history of concussions would scare me a bit.

I would be trading down.......

steve:clanram:

Greenway. No doubt.

Greenway, He's more of a strongside linbacker. Sims is quick & hits hard but i think he absorbes the impact of those hits to much.

I honestly think that Simms may turn out to be the better of the two. I think he's all-pro material.
But as Nick said, his history of concussions would scare me away. They are cumulative, so each time you get one, more damage is done. So his career could be short lived, especially the way he plays.

You can't be wrong with this one. I'd take either, however it appears to me that Greenway is the better player and Sims is the better athlete.

Maybe it's just me, but I'd take the player over the athlete.

Greenway, the Anquan Boldin of this draft. Poor workout but a through and through football player.

I'd go with 16

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by HUbison

Maybe it's just me, but I'd take the player over the athlete.

---

I would too, but Simms is as much a player as he is an athlete. I only prefer Greenway due to the concussion issue.

Greenway. I know I'm an Iowa fan and don't get me wrong Sims is going to do great things at the WLB spot. But Greenway is more of a SLB than the too. I like Sims but the only thing that concerns me like Nick is his concussions.

susceptibility to concussions = bad news for RB's, QB's, LB's, and Safeties. Just say no. I'd go Greenway.

I think you could trade down and get greenway 5 spots later

Take Greenway or trade down... Maybe trade down and still get Greenway!!