Value for Umenyiora

What would you be willing to trade for Osi Umenyiora if he's available?

i voted a 4th..would prefer a 5th and perhaps a conditional pick next year say a 3rd if he played in every game or got 8 sacks..something like that. but it wasnt an option so i picked 4th...3rd is too high i think with his knee history..even tho two years since it..it may be fine now.

considering the players that have been traded for fith rounders recently, i think a fifth rounder could happen, but a fourth is more likely. would obviously prefer if the Rams could get him for a fifth though!

why don't we just send the pick we got from AC red rover red rover send it on over :P

Billy Devaney or any other GM would probably only give up a fifth or a fourth.

However, I would give up a third. I just have faith that he will return to the Osi of Old, and that would be a huge upgrade for our defense.

Well Billy devaney is our GM and the only way we trade draft picks is by moving up and down in rounds. (like Carriker and Robinson)

So it will be Rams 2nd and 4th for the Giants 2nd and 5th

Or something stupid like that.

I'd say a late 3rd, but since we're at the top of the round, I'd be happy to give up our 4th for him. Even with the knee troubles, which are hopefully past him, to have him reunited with the coach that made him a star would be huge.

would love to give a 3rd next year for the guy (or 4th this year)


voted 3rd

I voted 5th but only because he was benched last year.