No announcement yet.

Best QB Packages

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Best QB Packages

    Raiders have the NFL's best posse of passers

    by Adrian Hasenmayer -

    Quarterback is still king and rates as the most important position on the field, but in today's NFL teams often go through as many as three QBs in simply surviving the regular season. Even with rules slanted to protect the passer, a strong benefits package is suggested if you're an NFL quarterback.

    So which teams are best positioned to not just survive, but flourish at quarterback in 2004? For the purposes of our rankings, the goal for every team is to find two, if not three, guys with plenty of experience. A great starting QB alone is most important, but a lack of solid backups can mean a big drop. Super Bowl experience definitely helps, since it's all about winning. Also, this list is for the 2004 season. Future potential means next to nothing.

    Ranking the QB Packages

    1. RAIDERS
    Rich Gannon
    Kerry Collins
    Marques Tuiasosopo
    Tee Martin
    Bret Engemann

    The Raiders have taken care of any QB questions and may the best man win between Gannon and Collins. Both have led teams to the Super Bowl and Gannon's a former league MVP. Even third-stringer Tuiasosopo has produced in limited action, giving Oakland a trio to bank on in case of injury. Nice balance age-wise, too, as Gannon (37) could be the man of the moment, Collins (31) for 2005-06 and Tuiasosopo (25) the QB of the future.

    2. EAGLES
    Donovan McNabb
    Koy Detmer
    Jeff Blake
    Andy Hall

    Philly's Andy Reid learned the importance of QB depth in 2002 when McNabb got hurt and missed the last six games, only to have Detmer and A.J. Feeley (now in Miami) go 5-1 as starters down the stretch. That's why he added Jeff Blake to the mix after dealing away Feeley, and so far Blake has looked right at home in Reid's West Coast offense in mini-camps.

    3. PACKERS
    Brett Favre
    Tim Couch
    Craig Nall
    Doug Pederson
    Scott McBrien

    Some may wonder why the Packers even employ backup quarterbacks on their roster? The last time Brett Favre missed a start, the original George Bush was still president. But with Favre moving up in years, Green Bay made a strong addition at backup QB with former No. 1 overall pick Tim Couch. Also, don't forget Doug Pederson, probably the most complimented clipboard holder in football history.

    Jake Delhomme
    Rodney Peete
    Chris Weinke
    Rob Adamson
    Rod Rutherford

    OK, all of you who see this group and can't believe it's ranked this high, open your eyes. Jake Delhomme might not be the flashiest guy, but only one passer was more clutch last season a man named Brady. Carolina agreed, having just inked the Ragin' Cajun to a five-year contract extension. Throw in Peete, a solid backup with plenty of experience, and even Weinke, and the Panthers have three guys who could take them to the playoffs.

    5. BUCS
    Brad Johnson
    Brian Griese
    Chris Simms
    Jason Garrett

    The NFL's deepest group still may not fully satisfy Jon Gruden's tastes, but perhaps no QB package is better prepared in case of a run of injuries. Despite rumors that Gruden wants another guy taking snaps, Brad Johnson owns a Super Bowl ring and he was NOT Tampa's problem last year (ask Warren Sapp about late-game defensive tank jobs). Griese has experience and plenty to prove, Garrett has backed up Troy Aikman flawlessy and Simms may be Tampa's QB of the future sooner than you think.

    6. CHIEFS
    Trent Green
    Todd Collins
    Damon Huard
    Marc Dunn
    Kirk Farmer
    Seth Burford
    Casey Clausen

    Think Dick Vermeil knows the importance of strong backup QBs? He wouldn't have won a ring in St. Louis without Kurt Warner, so in case Trent Green goes down again, KC has two guys the franchise feels can run the team in Collins and Huard. Vermeil also has four other guys to get a look at during training camp to see if he can uncover another gem.

    Tom Brady
    Rohan Davey
    Kliff Kingsbury

    If Davey is as good as he looked in leading the Berlin Thunder to a World Bowl title, then the Pats' group leaps much higher. But without any real experience behind football's reigning deity, the Pats have serious questions if Brady goes down. His two Super Bowl rings, developing aura and consummate leadership actually slot the Pats higher than some teams with two strong QBs.

    8. TITANS
    Steve McNair
    Billy Volek
    Jason Gesser

    Tennessee has monitored its QBs very well under Jeff Fisher. The team's patient approach in bringing along McNair paid off, as he is one of the best and toughest players in the league. Volek was groomed to be McNair's backup while the team had Neil O'Donnell around, and last year Volek proved very capable when McNair missed his usual set of games with injury. Now the Titans will stash former Washington State QB Jason Gesser away until he ripens in a couple years.

    Matt Hasselbeck
    Trent Dilfer
    Seneca Wallace
    Brock Huard

    Mike Holmgren isn't sleepless in Seattle anymore about his feisty QB. Once way too headstrong for his own good, Hasselbeck is maturing and finally bought into the system leading to Pro Bowl numbers. He may never be the next Favre, but he seems primed to blossom completely in 2004. Trent Dilfer is one of football's most solid team guys and has a Super Bowl ring on his resume. The young Wallace is talented, and local boy Brock Huard is no stiff.

    10. VIKINGS
    Daunte Culpepper
    Gus Frerotte
    Shaun Hill
    Matt Kegel

    Now that Culpepper seems to have cut down enough on turnover-itis, the Vikings' group can reside in the top 10. The next step for Culpepper will be getting the Vikings back in the playoffs, much of which depends on the Minnesota defense, of course. Last season, Gus Frerotte subbed for the starter in two games, winning both, putting up big numbers and proving he is solid insurance in case the mobile Culpepper gets dinged.

    11. COLTS
    Peyton Manning
    Cory Sauter
    Jim Sorgi
    Tom Arth
    Joe Hamilton

    Even with arguably the best quarterback in the league, this may be a bit high for the simple reason that if Manning ever does get injured, this position is one HUGE question mark. The other four QBs on the roster have one game of NFL experience combined. Manning has started every game in his six-year career and could be another Favre in terms of durability, but the lack of any seasoned backup is striking. Manning's greatness and reliability alone keep the Colts this high, but Tony Dungy had better not break any mirrors.

    12. REDSKINS
    Mark Brunell
    Patrick Ramsey
    Tim Hasselbeck
    Gilbran Hamdan

    This group doesn't have the juice of other individual QBs, but forget about 2003. Brunell is still a dependable QB who can win in this league, but he was on a Jags team in rebuilding mode. Ramsey was in the worst situation in football as a pocket punching bag in Steve Spurrier's failed offense. But both these guys are solid, tough players whom Washington can build around. Even Tim Hasselbeck has some experience, giving Joe Gibbs a fine posse of passers to work with.

    13. RAMS
    Marc Bulger
    Chris Chandler
    Jeff Smoker
    Russ Michna

    In St. Louis, why do the backup QBs always seem to save the team? Marc Bulger had better stay healthy this year. The Rams might have picked the right starter by cutting Kurt Warner and re-signing Bulger, but eyebrows were raised with the off-season addition of extremely brittle Chris Chandler. He has reached the Super Bowl as a starter, but should have retired years ago. Third-stringer Jeff Smoker may be a sleeper, but is only a rookie.

    14. FALCONS
    Michael Vick
    Ty Detmer
    Matt Schaub
    Bill Whittemore

    Vick is brilliant and awe-inspiring, but until he learns when not to fling his body around like a kamakaze and stays healthy for a whole season again, the Falcons will stay in the middle of the pack. I'm not sold on the so-called improvement at backup QB, as Ty Detmer could not even beat out Charlie Batch a few years ago in Detroit.

    15. GIANTS
    Kurt Warner
    Eli Manning
    Jesse Palmer
    Ryan Van Dyke
    Kevin Thompson
    Jared Lorenzen

    The Giants were wise to gamble on Warner's thumb and head being healthy, seeing as they chased off incumbent Kerry Collins after mortgaging a chunk of the future in drafting Eli Manning. Forget Eli's potential; this is about 2004 and he's just another wide-eyed rookie. But we still don't know which Warner will show up in the Big Apple, the two-time MVP or the guy who hasn't won a start since 2001. And don't get me started on The Bachelor. Still, GM Ernie Accorsi has filled the roster with options.

    16. COWBOYS
    Quincy Carter
    Vinny Testaverde
    Drew Henson
    Chad Hutchinson
    Tony Romo

    I still don't buy Quincy Carter as a championship quarterback, but he did get Dallas back to the playoffs last year. Adding Testaverde was an excellent move by Tuna and Jerry, the only experienced guy in Big D who may end up bailing this team out in 2004. Drew Henson is a great prospect for '05 and beyond who Dallas hopes is not another Chad Hutchinson, who seems lost.

    17. BROWNS
    [i]Jeff Garcia
    Kelly Holcomb
    Luke McCown
    Nate Hybl
    Todd Husak
    With apologies to Terrell Owens, new Browns starter Jeff Garcia is still a fine quarterback. He may not have the big arm, but he is a good leader and can move the chains. He should fit very well in Cleveland, especially with Kellen Winslow as his new tight end. Holcomb is back where he belongs, as the backup QB who can rally his team in emergencies.

    18. JETS
    Chad Pennington
    Brooks Bollinger
    Ricky Ray
    Chris Finlen

    A group headlined by Pennington should rank much higher, but losing Vinny to Dallas leaves a collection with as many NFL passes as you and me combined ZERO. Brooks Bollinger is an unknown NFL-wise and will have to prove himself at some point. No, Ricky Ray is not the same character from Blue Chips, but he's the reigning stud out of the CFL who could become the No. 2 QB this season. The Jets will hold their breath the entire season watching Pennington.

    19. BENGALS
    Carson Palmer
    Jon Kitna
    Casey Bramlet
    Scott Rislov

    Cincinnati keeps telling everyone that former Heisman Trophy winner Carson Palmer is ready to start and win now. They'd better be right, but it sure is nice to have Kitna behind him coming off a career year. If the Bengals start slowly, Kitna may be thrown back on the field as a savior a role that may fit the deeply religious QB.

    20. SAINTS
    Aaron Brooks
    Todd Bouman
    J.T. O'Sullivan

    Brooks is proven when it comes to numbers, but not yet in terms of winning. He does have the skills to lead the Saints back to postseason play, and should excel in '04 with a healthy Donte Stallworth to pair with Pro Bowl-caliber wideout Joe Horn. Bouman and O'Sullivan have both been stars in NFL Europe, but only Bouman owns any reasonable NFL success, while backing up Daunte Culpepper in Minnesota.

    21. CHARGERS
    Drew Brees
    Philip Rivers
    Doug Flutie
    Cleo Lemon

    Brees may or may not be finished in San Diego, but it certainly seems premature to bury the guy at age 25. Even if Brees fails miserably this season, No. 1 draft pick Rivers and the veteran Flutie are quality insurance for the rebuilding Bolts.

    22. DOLPHINS
    Jay Fiedler
    A.J. Feeley
    Sage Rosenfels
    Clint Stoerner

    The timing has been off in Miami for decades. When the Dolphins had Dan Marino, they couldn't find a running game. Now they've got RB Ricky Williams, but constant questions at QB. Jay Fielder isn't the league's best passer, but he is a gamer who is good enough to get Miami to the playoffs just not the Super Bowl. But is A.J. Feeley? Miami might have overpaid to get Feeley from Philly.

    23. STEELERS
    Tommy Maddox
    Ben Roethlisberger
    Charlie Batch
    Brian Pierre

    This group is not earth-shattering now, but it could be eventually if Roethlisberger lives up to his pre-draft hype. Tommy Maddox got his new contract and should hold the position with respectability in '04, but the ex-XFL champion is still not the greatest No. 1 in the league. Charlie Batch gives the Steelers an experienced option at third string, giving them some depth. But the chances of Roethlisberger becoming Bradshaw overnight are slim.

    24. BILLS
    Drew Bledsoe
    Travis Brown
    J.P. Losman
    Greg Zolman
    Nathan Chandler

    How far has Drew Bledsoe's stock sunk? The play of the former No. 1 overall draft pick and three-time 4,000-yard passer plummeted to shocking levels in 2003. Was Peerless Price that important to this passing game? Bledsoe needs a major rebound this year. Travis Brown has thrown 52 NFL passes without a start. Buffalo seems sold on first-rounder Losman, who is very ****y or confident, depending on your perspective.

    25. BRONCOS
    Jake Plummer
    Mike Quinn
    Danny Kanell
    Matt Mauck
    Bradlee Van Pelt

    Denver's season went south a year ago once Plummer got hurt as coach Mike Shanahan scrambled without a quality No. 2 or No. 3 QB. It doesn't seem like a problem solved. Plummer can win in Denver, but must stay healthy. The Broncos added backup QB Mike Quinn, a seven-year veteran with three NFL passes under his wristbands. Danny Kanell was one of 2003's main culprits (2 TD, 5 INT, 49.1 rating).

    26. LIONS
    Joey Harrington
    Mike McMahon
    Rick Mirer
    Curt Anes
    Jason Fife

    The pressure's on Harrington in Year Three as a franchise QB, especially with all the fun toys he gets to play with (exciting rookie RB Kevin Jones, WR duo of Charlie Rogers and Roy Williams). If he falters, Steve Mariucci likely will not hesitate to put McMahon in the lineup for a shot. Rick Mirer might be one of the worst first-round draft picks ever, but is perfectly suited here as a No. 3 quarterback.

    27. RAVENS
    Kyle Boller
    Kordell Stewart
    Anthony Wright
    Josh Harris
    Brian Gaither

    If Boller is healthy and lives up to Brian Billick's expectations, this group can make a big move up this list. Otherwise, this team's depending on Kordell Stewart to, well ... hand the ball off and not screw things up. The injured Wright was a pleasant surprise in 2003, but won't return to the field until November. Billick's got to be wondering if he'll EVER get a decent QB in Baltimore.

    28. TEXANS
    David Carr
    Tony Banks
    Dave Ragone
    B.J. Symons

    David Carr will be a fixture with this team for years and was an excellent choice as Houston's first-ever draft pick three years ago. With an improving offense around him, he could flourish in '04. Tony Banks is still Tony Banks, but at least he has taken a few NFL snaps before.

    29. JAGUARS
    Byron Leftwich
    David Garrard
    Doug Johnson
    Quinn Gray

    The low ranking does not reflect views on the talent of Leftwich, who could be the best young quarterback in the NFL. But he still has yet to prove himself in the big leagues. Behind the prodigy is a decent prospect in second-year man David Garrard, but also Doug Johnson an utter failure in Atlanta last season.

    Josh McCown
    Shaun King
    John Navarre
    Chris Lewis

    New Cards coach Dennis Green shocked the NFL by announcing Josh McCown as his starting QB at the beginning of off-season, with some other big names available. It may be even more shocking that he has not budged from this yet. If McCown is not the second coming of Neil Lomax, then at least they added a decent backup in former Buc Shaun King. John Navarre led Michigan to the Rose Bowl in 2003. Can he become another Tom Brady? If so, certainly not yet.

    31. BEARS
    Rex Grossman
    Jonathan Quinn
    Craig Krenzel
    Ryan Dinwiddle

    It's Rex Grossman's ship to steer in just his second year, and with questionable talent around him. The jury's out on whether his lack of size will hurt his NFL production. Jonathan Quinn's six-year totals: three NFL starts, three TD passes. Third-stringer Craig Krenzel got plenty of big-game experience in college at Ohio State, but this is the real world for a rookie.

    32. *****
    Tim Rattay
    Ken Dorsey
    Brandon Doman
    Cody Pickett

    Has it really come to this for the *****, the franchise of some of football's best all-time quarterbacks? With the divorce with Jeff Garcia finalized, it's major rebuilding time in 'Frisco. Rattay proved capabale enough in '03 (especially if you ask Terrell Owens), but will likely miss the start of the season to injury. That leaves Ken Dorsey, two years removed from an incredible college career at Miami. Word is he has added some bulk and has impressed the organization with his intensity and work ethic. But at the moment, this group is an embarrassment to the state of ***** football.

  • #2
    Re: Best QB Packages

    LOL look who is last on the list. :redface:


    Related Topics


    • AugustaRamFan
      More Rankings - RAMS QBs...
      by AugustaRamFan
      Here is a snippet from Fox News Hounds....

      ESPN had the Rams QB triumverate at #11....see where they ended up for FOX. Granted - it is a Fantasy Ranking, but still. Ya gotta like #3!!

      Nothing stirs up debate like a good set of rankings, and ranking all 32 NFL teams unit-by-unit is an annual tradition. This year, the debate comes with a little twist, as our rankings are grounded not in the conventional wisdom but in the advanced statistics of Football Outsiders.

      Fantasy Football Draft Guide

      Transform draft day into a title!

      Player rankings and projections
      Expert drafts
      Sleepers, flops
      Coaching styles
      Fantasy depth charts

      Any discussion of an NFL team usually starts with the quarterback, and our rankings are no exception. Rating quarterbacks as a unit means taking into account more than just the first-stringer on each team. However, quarterback is very different from other positions, because the bench players only see action if the starter is injured. So a lack of depth at quarterback is less of an issue than it is at other positions. (We're looking at you, Patriots.)

      Since we'll be rating each unit as it exists in 2006, we're taking into account performance over the last couple of years, but we're also considering age and injuries. All those teams whose starting quarterbacks are still iffy for the start of the 2006 season get penalized, as do teams whose quarterbacks are currently healthy but have a bad injury record. It's better for your backup to be a first-round rookie with potential than a mediocre journeyman, but Tennessee doesn't get to rank higher because Vince Young might be the best quarterback in football five years from now. Our judgment of inexperienced quarterbacks is guided in part by our new rookie quarterback projection system, the subject of a long essay in our upcoming book Pro Football Prospectus 2006. You can read an introduction to the system here.

      You'll see a lot of stats you recognize here, and one you may not: DPAR, or Defense-adjusted Points Above Replacement. DPAR takes every single play during the season and compares it to the league average based on situation and opponent, rewarding players for strong performance on third down and in the red zone and giving them less credit for meaningless gains like a six-yard scramble on third-and-12. For those interested, you can find all the 2005 DPAR numbers for quarterbacks on this page.

      Without further ado, here's a list of the NFL's quarterback units from best to worst.

      1. Indianapolis
      If you have been reading Football Outsiders over the past couple years, you know that there is no topic in football that we despise more than the never-ending, always irrational debate over who is the best quarterback in the NFL, Tom Brady or Peyton Manning. But since we're rating...
      -07-11-2006, 11:50 AM
    • Nick
      SI's Top 10 available QBs
      by Nick
      Top 10 available QBs
      The best of a weak crop of potential free agents
      Posted: Wednesday February 16, 2005 4:34PM; Updated: Wednesday February 16, 2005 5:51PM

      Late winter is a dangerous time for quarterbacks with big salaries. The announcements that Jeff Garcia and Drew Bledsoe will be cut have brought the 2005 free-agent crop into focus for the handful of teams that need either a starter or an experienced backup to mentor a young QB.

      The two most exciting free agents, San Diego's Drew Brees and Seattle's MattHasselbeck, likely will re-sign with their current teams, so they don't make the shopping list. That leaves several players on the downside or the very last breath of their careers.

      They may not be the pick of the litter, but many teams have won Super Bowls with former castaways. With an eye toward that diamond in the rough, here's the top 10 most attractive potential free-agent quarterbacks in 2005.

      1. Brian Griese: After starting the season as the third QB, Griese compiled a 97.5 passer rating in 11 games with the Bucs last season, proving to be an efficient quarterback in JonGruden's system. But he's due a $6 million bonus in March and the Bucs need to renegotiate that deal in the next couple of weeks or cut him. Griese's success last year did a lot to erase the memories of his disastrous tenure in Miami and his troublesome demise in Denver. Of all the players on this list, the 29-year-old Griese has the best upside. At his best, he's the kind of QB that doesn't make mistakes and can run an offense efficiently, in the same vain as his old Michigan teammate Tom Brady.

      2. Drew Bledsoe: His numbers plummeted steadily during three years in Buffalo, from 4,359 passing yards in 2001 to 2,932 last year. But those numbers are a reflection of the change in offensive philosophy more than a decline in Bledsoe's talent. And since Peerless Price left for Atlanta in 2003, Bledsoe hasn't had a secondary receiving threat to complement Eric Moulds. Bledsoe's arm strength is still there, and he's never been able to run, so his 33-year-old legs aren't really an issue. Since Buffalo announced it would release him, there's rampant speculation Bledsoe will be reunited with Bill Parcells in Dallas, where he'd be a spring chicken compared to the last quarterback, Vinny Testaverde (see No. 10).

      3. Jeff Garcia: We learned two things about Garcia from his performance in Cleveland in 2004. First, he can't play in a system that isn't similar to the *****' West Coast attack. Secondly, he must have had some talent to run San Francisco's offense, because the ***** couldn't move the ball without him. OK, the Niners also missed Terrell Owens, but don't discount Garcia's achievements -- three Pro Bowls and an average of 3,281 passing yards per season over five years in San Francisco. For teams that run West Coast offenses, Garcia seems like a decent risk...
      -02-18-2005, 01:22 PM
    • HUbison
      This year's "headset to helmet" award goes to....
      by HUbison
      It happens every year. Some no name QB watches as the starter gets a late hit from Rodney Harrison that breaks his leg, and the no-name grocery store clerk is propelled into a league MVP and Super Bowl Champion!

      Okay, maybe THAT doesn't happen every year, but each season will have at least one story of a back-up QB receiving his moment in the spotlight. No, we can't predict injuries, but that notwithstanding, who do you see as the 2nd stringer with the best chance of breaking through the golden veil of NFL starting QB?

      Here's the choices (projected starter in para.) :

      AFC East

      Miami Dolphins (Trent Green) - Cleo Lemon, John Beck, Dante Culpepper
      NY Jets (Chad Pennington) - Kellen Clemens, Marques Tuiasosopo
      NE Patriots (Tom Brady) - Matt Cassell, Vinny Testaverde
      Buffalo Bills (JP Losman) - Craig Nall, Trent Edwards

      AFC North

      Baltimore Ravens (Steve McNair) - Kyle Boller, Troy Smith
      Pittsburgh Steelers (Ben Rothleisberger) - Charlie Batch, Brian St. Pierre
      Cleveland Browns (no clear starter) - Charlie Frye, Derek Anderson, Brady Quinn
      Cincinatti Bengals (Carson Palmer) - Doug Johnson, Jeff Rowe

      AFC South

      Indy Colts (Peyton Manning) - Jim Sorgi, John Navarre
      Tenn. Titans (Vince Young) - Kerry Collins, Tim Rattay
      Houston Texans (Matt Shaub)- Sage Rosenfels, Bradlee Van Pelt, Quinton Porter
      Jax Jaguars (Byron Leftwich) - David Garrard, Quinn Gray

      AFC West

      KC Chiefs (no clear starter) - Brodie Croyle, Damon Huard, Casey Printers
      Oakland Raiders (no clear starter) - Josh McCown, JaMarcus Russell, Andrew Walter, Josh Booty
      Denver Broncos (Jay Cutler) - Patrick Ramsey, Preston Parsons
      SD Chargers (Phillip Rivers) - Billy Volek, Charlie Whitehurst

      NFC East

      Philly Eagles (Donovan McNabb) - A.J. Feeley, Kevin Kolb, Kelly Holcomb
      Wash Redskins (Jason Campbell) - Mark Brunnell, Jordan Palmer
      Dallas Cowboys (Tony Romo) - Brad Johnson, Isaiah Stanback
      NY Giants (Eli Manning) - Anthony Wright, Tim Hasselbeck, Jared Lorenzen

      NFC North

      Detroit Lions (John Kitna) - Dan Orlovsky, Drew Stanton
      GB Packers (Brett Favre) - Aaron Rodgers, Ingle Martin, Todd Bouman
      Minny Vikings (Tavaris Jackson) - Brooks Bollinger, Tyler Thigpen
      Chicago Bears (Rex Grossman) - Brian Griese, Kyle Orton, Chris Leak

      NFC South

      TB Bucs (no clear starter) - Jeff Garcia, Jake Plummer, Chris Simms, Bruce Gradkowski
      NO Saints (Drew Brees) - Jamie Martin, Jason Fife
      Carolina Panthers (Jake Delhomme) - David Carr, Brett Basanez
      Atlanta Falcons (Michael Vick) - Joey Harrington, DJ Shockley

      NFC West

      St. Louis Rams (Mark Bulger) - Gus Frerotte, Ryan Fitzpatrick
      Seattle Seahawks (Matt...
      -07-07-2007, 11:32 AM
    • The Special One
      Possible destinations for Brett Favre
      by The Special One
      In this post, I will break down, from #32 to #1, which teams could use Brett Favre the most and follow that up with a short explanation.

      32. Green Bay. They seem ready to move on with Aaron Rodgers. They're the ones who want to get rid of him. Enough said.

      31. New England. Two words...Tom Brady.

      30. Indianapolis. Again, two words...Peyton Manning.

      29. New York Giants. They just won a Super Bowl with Eli and are thus set to move on with Manning as their starting QB.

      28. Jacksonville. David Garrard fits their run-oriented offense very well, and IMO, was snubbed from the Pro Bowl last season.

      27. Cincinnati. Carson Palmer is a stud at the QB position and is a former #1 overall pick. The problem with that team is the defense and running game, not Carson Palmer.

      26. Pittsburgh. Although I have my doubts about Big Ben, the Steelers just awarded him with a big contract and he is coming off a Pro Bowl season.

      25. San Diego. Philip Rivers showed his guts in the playoffs when he played through injury (and even played very well at times). He's a former top five pick who seems to be the future of this team at QB.

      24. Seattle. Even though Brett would love to fling the ball around in this pass-heavy offense with old coach Mike Holmgren for one last year, Matt Hasselbeck, a former backup QB behind Brett, is a Pro Bowl QB and is the QB of this franchise.

      23. New Orleans. Drew Bress is a top-tier QB if his offensive line can protect him and if key players on offense can stay healthy. Look for Brees to have a Pro Bowl-caliber season this year. Drew is the QB of this franchise.

      22. Philadelphia. Donovan McNabb is a top five QB in the NFL if he can stay healthy. Look for McNabb to have a Pro Bowl season this year. Plus, Philly already has its QB of the future in Kevin Kolb, who they drafted early in the second round last year from Houston.

      21. Cleveland. Sure, Brett would love to throw to all those weapons on offense, but acquiring Brett would give the Browns a mosh pit at QB of heavily paid guys. I'm not too sure Brady Quinn, the Browns likely QB of the future, would be particularly fond of being #3 on the depth chart (as he's already having trouble accepting a backup role).

      20. St. Louis. Marc Bulger is a top ten QB in the league when healthy, and thus, I'm not too sure we'd be willing to take on Brett just for the sake of one season. Besides, at this point, Bulger is as good a QB as Favre and will be way better this season if he can avoid injury.

      19. Kansas City. Another team in total rebuilding mode which wouldn't make much sense to take on Brett's salary and prevent Brodie Croyle from gaining experience and chemistry with his teammates.

      18. Atlanta. Same as above with the Chiefs and Dolphins. Matt Ryan needs all the experience and time (to develop chemistry with his...
      -07-24-2008, 05:16 AM
    • DJRamFan
      [Whiners] Quality draft pick could be silver lining in *****' lousy season
      by DJRamFan
      Ira Miller

      Wednesday, December 1, 2004

      The so-called franchise quarterback is back in vogue in the NFL, and the ***** need one. Because of their lousy season, they'll have a chance to get one, too.

      Tim Rattay could be serviceable if he had a decent supporting cast, but he is not a player to build a team around. Quarterback Matt Leinart of USC appears he could be, and so he's the answer to the most popular question in town this week:

      What should the ***** do with the first choice in the 2005 draft?

      Help is needed at a lot of positions, but it is becoming increasingly clear in today's NFL that the franchise quarterback is key, and when you have a chance to get one, you'd better do it.

      "They're hard to come by," said Bill Polian, president of the Indianapolis Colts, a team that has no quarterback problem. "If you don't have a good one who can lead you from behind, who can win games in the fourth quarter, then you have to have an absolutely dominant defense and you must have a dominant running game and you must have a dominant kicking game. It's that simple. That's the formula if you don't have the quarterback."

      Clearly, the ***** are dominant in no area, which is why they have the inside track on the first pick next April.

      In four games since returning from his latest injury, Rattay has been abysmal in the fourth quarter, losing seven turnovers and compiling a passer rating of 46.2. In the last three weeks, the ***** lost consecutive games against teams that were a combined 5-22 before playing San Francisco, and Rattay lost a total of nine turnovers in those three games.

      It's not all Rattay's fault, obviously. He is surrounded by little talent at wide receiver and running back and operates an ill-conceived offensive scheme behind a horrid offensive line. But to win, a team needs a quarterback who can rise above the players around him. Rattay is little more than a decent backup who needs everything around him to be perfect to succeed.

      NFL scouts believe Leinart has an edge on Cal's Aaron Rodgers as the best quarterback likely to be in the draft; both are juniors and can't declare their draft eligibility until after bowl games. Scouts say Leinart is more instinctive; Rodgers appears somewhat mechanical at times. The differences, however, are small, and opinions could -- and probably will -- change many times between now and April.

      What the ***** have to hope is that one of them becomes a stud, that this draft -- considered weak by most experts -- doesn't turn out like 1994, when the first-round quarterbacks were Trent Dilfer and Heath Shuler.

      A franchise quarterback does not have to come from the top tier of the draft, of course. New England got lucky late with Tom Brady. San Diego's Drew Brees, a candidate both for MVP and comeback player of the...
      -12-04-2004, 03:10 PM