Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

    Here is my agrument not to draft a RB until round 5 or later(if at all).

    1. SJAX is elite back . He will want a ton of carries and catches. He is rare 3 down back. He will be happy the more he is out there.

    2. 2 backs with a star in front doesn't = any more wins (LT sproles, AP C.Taylor , etc)

    3. The Oline makes the backup RB. ex. D.Ward found cut off Practice squad. Patriots throw anyone back there as #2 RB with success. #2 Backs should fit your system and excel in the limited action for blocking, change of pace, speed.

    Prime example is --> T. Choice Cowboys. Good O-Line people thought F.Jones was amazing, then when T. Choice was given some time he worked great as well. If F.Jones was on the Bengals last year he would have done squat.

    4. If we drafted someone like Ian Johnson, McCoy, etc. They will want touches and if successful demand to be traded or paid since they are picked high in the draft and want to start. Creates a bad situation.

    5. Darby and Pittman looked ok. I think if we started the season with the addition of Brown, Fells, Karney, and a healthy McMichael or blocking would be alot better.


    6. Finally, we have other needs that are much more important.


    LB, DT, OL, WR = four biggest needs (first four rounds)

    If I have to pick a 5th need it would be pass Rushing End.


    so that makes #2 RB our 6th need or 7th if you want another CB first.



    Just my take on it all

  • #2
    Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

    We dont need a pass rushing end because we have Chris Long and Leonard Little!!!

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

      Long seems to be progressing and hopefully Little has one maybe 2 years left but they didn't seem to do much last year.

      Maybe a Big DT will help them next to AC, we will see.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

        No, drafting an RB at #2 could make sense. The Giants had 3 backs, the Broncos went through 8 last year. 8! Jackson has gone down with some type of injury or another every year it seems like. Chargers have 2. Panthers have 2. Leonard and Darby haven't proved anything to me and this team needs everything. So yes, it does make perfect sense to me.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

          Originally posted by txramsfan View Post
          No, drafting an RB at #2 could make sense. The Giants had 3 backs, the Broncos went through 8 last year. 8! Jackson has gone down with some type of injury or another every year it seems like. Chargers have 2. Panthers have 2. Leonard and Darby haven't proved anything to me and this team needs everything. So yes, it does make perfect sense to me.
          Ohyeah,

          and Bradshaw and Ward

          Bradshaw was a 7th rounder

          Ward picked up of jets practice squad cuts

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

            Fine, however this Rams team needs alot. I don't care when they draft any position. Most of you "draftnix" have it all broken down to a science......allegedly but this team needs everything and if they decide that a RB is needed in Round 2 I'm fine with it.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

              Originally posted by richtree View Post
              Ohyeah,

              and Bradshaw and Ward

              Bradshaw was a 7th rounder

              Ward picked up of jets practice squad cuts
              (1st) Jonathan Stewart (Williams), Felix Jones (Barber), Chris Johnson (White), Rashard Mendenhall (Willie)
              (2nd) Maurice Jones-Drew (Taylor)
              (3rd) Jerious Norwood (Dunn, Turner)
              (4th) Brandon Jacobs (Tiki), Darren Sproles (LT), Leon Washington (Jones), Steve Slaton (Green)

              Those players are reasons you draft #2 RBs high. Finding undrafted ones are mostly luck, not skill.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                every player you listed is on a team with a good offensive line

                you post defends my point

                t. choice filled in just fine for cowboys

                M.Moore was the option in Pitt -- Mendenhall didn't shine

                Chris Johnson and J. Stewart look good #1 backs...

                but we are looking for a #2 back

                after you listed the backs that came out of the 3rd and 4th round that are successful it proves we can wait til that time of the draft.

                No one said he can't draft one in the 4th/5th/6th round...

                #2 Rb will play 12 snaps a game tops - probably less

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                  Originally posted by richtree View Post
                  2. 2 backs with a star in front doesn't = any more wins (LT sproles, AP C.Taylor , etc)
                  Both of those teams went to the playoffs, no? It seems like having two backs may indeed help with more wins.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                    Taylor was taken with the 35th pick in the 6th round

                    Sproles was drafted the Chargers in the fourth round of the 2005 draft

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                      Even bearing in mind Tx's valid point about all positions needing at least depth,Richtree, I'm not sure who is arguing seriously for a RB at that spot. The poll just a few threads down overwhelmingly rejected either of the 2 top prospects.If the argument is being made, it ain't here.

                      Bottom line for me, I think that 2nd rounder needs to at least be in contention for a starter spot.

                      That's only true @ RB if SJ is hurt.

                      Could be true for any other position except QB, kicker,center,and safety. And that's probably only so because we have dropped mega-quan bombs on those positions for 2009's salary cap already.

                      tx, why can't Leonard be a good-sized but versatile back-up behind a better FB & O-line, just like Ward did? Didn't he get a 100yder behind the infamous 2007 Colander line?

                      Granted there are injury,misuse, and bust warning lights over the RB depth spot but there are others closer to being gaping holes like CB,WR,NT,DE,and LB-in no paricular order- that can be better filled by the likely prospects available, it seems to me.

                      Prioritizing that short list is where the draftniks lose me. Like trying to decide whether it's better to be a homeowner in Fallujah or Detroit.

                      Or to be born with one testicle or in Texas.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                        Leonard could be a good back but he's unproven. You are right blue and gold, I am not advocating taking a RB in Round 2 but I also don't see the harm. I mean some people on here are adamant about Curry in the 2nd overall slot but that makes no sense to me. Who is the last OLB to dominate the NFL? And another thing, that little experiment with Carriker moving him from DE in college to DT in the pros has worked out really well.....not. I'm not a big advocate of selecting a player high then moving them to a position that they "grade out" to.

                        No, I'm not saying we should take a RB in Round 2 but I'm also not saying we shouldn't.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                          No, I'm not saying we should take a RB in Round 2 but I'm also not saying we shouldn't.[/quote]


                          I AM saying we shouldn't Our first 4 rounds should attack

                          LB, NT, WR, OL --

                          Unless there is someone that really stands out in round 3 or 4 -- we shouldn't have any RB's / QB's / Secondary Players in the first 4 rounds

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                            Originally posted by txramsfan View Post
                            Leonard could be a good back but he's unproven. You are right blue and gold, I am not advocating taking a RB in Round 2 but I also don't see the harm. I mean some people on here are adamant about Curry in the 2nd overall slot but that makes no sense to me. Who is the last OLB to dominate the NFL? And another thing, that little experiment with Carriker moving him from DE in college to DT in the pros has worked out really well.....not. I'm not a big advocate of selecting a player high then moving them to a position that they "grade out" to.


                            No, I'm not saying we should take a RB in Round 2 but I'm also not saying we shouldn't.
                            "harm"? No, but I think there's a good case that a RB wouldn't be as likely to have an immediate benefit as ,say, a front 7 pick in the 2nd rd.I don't think that's splitting draftnik hairs.

                            I agree with you about Curry. That's taking the BPA thing too far.

                            Maybe even a CB makes better sense in Rd2, if we get someone like Sean Smith. Gives us nice flexibility- a "big' package in Bartell & Smith as well as some speedier guys.

                            I still think Carriker falls more into the Spoon at MLB category of expedience/experiment than a Crouch. Let's not Ryan Pickett the guy.With hindsight, was it a great pick? No, but neither moving nor replacing him seems to me to be an option right now.I'd like an Orakpo caliber replacement for Little,too,but I don't want it over an OT.

                            Maybe Carriker's very "tweener-ness" will be an advantage with Spags' creative D fronts.

                            I apologize for the testicle/Texas analogy. Must be the blackened trout I had last night fighting back on me. And maybe a little displaced taxpayer rage since I still haven't got my state return. F#$%ing Governator Arnie...

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Drafting a #2 RB High is a Waste of time

                              I disagree!!!!!!!!!

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              Here is my agrument not to draft a RB until round 5 or later(if at all).
                              Well IMO if there is not much value when the 3rd round comes i say get Rashad Jennings or wait till the 7th and get Devin Moore.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              1. SJAX is elite back . He will want a ton of carries and catches. He is rare 3 down back. He will be happy the more he is out there.
                              Yea the last 2 years he has out on the bench instead of out there. We need a CAPABLE back-up that can also split some carries with S-Jax. Sorry i said CAPABLE which means not Brian Leonard.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              2. 2 backs with a star in front doesn't = any more wins (LT sproles, AP C.Taylor , etc)
                              When LT was out the last 2 playoffs sproles and that guy on the Falcons (forgot name) came throught and got the Chargers the victory. And with our new power running game Action Jackson will get tired at times getting hit hard. S-Jax is not Superman.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              3. The Oline makes the backup RB. ex. D.Ward found cut off Practice squad. Patriots throw anyone back there as #2 RB with success. #2 Backs should fit your system and excel in the limited action for blocking, change of pace, speed.
                              Yea in the 3rd round Rashad Jennings fits our system. We are going to be a power running team and run down the middle Jennings is tall at 6-1 but he is really fast and has extremly good hands. He can also block really well.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              Prime example is --> T. Choice Cowboys. Good O-Line people thought F.Jones was amazing, then when T. Choice was given some time he worked great as well. If F.Jones was on the Bengals last year he would have done squat.
                              Well what about the Cardinals. They dont have a great O-line yet Hightower ran all over us.

                              And are you trying to insinuate that we have a Bad run blocking O-Line? Cuz with the addition of Brown our Guards should get better and Eugene Monroe can do a good job on the right side.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              4. If we drafted someone like Ian Johnson, McCoy, etc. They will want touches and if successful demand to be traded or paid since they are picked high in the draft and want to start. Creates a bad situation.
                              Iight if we draft a high round RB and they demand a trade to be a starter who will want them? Also mid round rookies dont often get long term deals. So if they feel like they can get better money elsewhere they can go as a RFA and we get a draft pick as compensation so i would not be too mad.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              5. Darby and Pittman looked ok. I think if we started the season with the addition of Brown, Fells, Karney, and a healthy McMichael or blocking would be alot better.
                              Pittman was injured while Jackson was out so i dont see how you call him OK. Darby fumbles too much but he can block.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              6. Finally, we have other needs that are much more important.

                              Originally posted by richtree View Post
                              LB, DT, OL, WR = four biggest needs (first four rounds)

                              If I have to pick a 5th need it would be pass Rushing End.


                              so that makes #2 RB our 6th need or 7th if you want another CB first.



                              Just my take on it all
                              Well i dont really like the idea of reaching just because it is a major need while there is great value for a minor need. Where is the back-up QB he deserves a 4th or 5th round.

                              I had a mock draft earlier called B-Dub's mock draft it is worth reading.

                              Comment

                              Related Topics

                              Collapse

                              • a.p.quinn
                                Backup RB
                                by a.p.quinn
                                If there's no one suitable shaken from the trees around the NFL to be no. 2. Need to sign a running back that can pass block. Doesn't have to be a great running back, just needs to be able to pass block. Darby can't, Toston isn't particularly good, Ogbannaya is iffy. That or just put a backup OG or DT in at running back on pass plays from time to time... Really bored, just thinking out loud.
                                -08-17-2010, 10:43 AM
                              • a.p.quinn
                                Drafting the right RB could fill multiple voids
                                by a.p.quinn
                                If the Rams pick the right back it'll be a smaller guy in the third or later. Someone who can block, fill slots as a receiver and be the number two halfback. Possibly be a return option in addition to Amendola. Although I wouldn't be against Ryan Mathews if he fell to the second (highly doubtful). It would have to be a change of pass back because that's the only way the Rams can get value. Jhavid Best, Dexter McCluster types. Get a guy to come in and do the Reggie Bush thang.

                                Sorry if this is another dull concept, but I'm getting too excited for draft time and just need to vent some bulls**t.
                                -04-04-2010, 11:54 AM
                              • LARAM
                                Drafting RB/FB positions
                                by LARAM
                                Although not a priority, What are some thoughts of drafting a RB/FB in the draft. We could use a decent back up to Steven Jackson, and special teams help.

                                What about Kenny Irons RB/Auburn...... possibly if left in the 3rd, or even in the second if we are able to address other needs by then.

                                or that FB from Rutgers (Brian Leonard), I saw him on ESPN and looked at some footage and.....(WOW). That guy looked good....Anyone know where he is projected to go in the draft. He can catch just like Steven Jackson...and he can run it to the side lines.
                                -02-18-2007, 02:52 PM
                              • A-Web
                                RB Depth and the 35th Pick
                                by A-Web
                                Not that I believe we have a bad running game. Obviously when Jackson is healthy it is one of the most dangerous in the league. Well, if our O-Line could produce for him. And I am sure they will in the near future.

                                Anyways, I was just wondering, because I was browsing some mocks and found something interesting.

                                In most mock drafts, it seems that there is only a single running back coming off the board in the first round. Knowshon Moreno. One draft, by Charles Davis of NFL.COM, whom I highly regard for his articles and opinions, had Knowshon as the only RB taken in round one. And the sad part was, he had him going to the Chargers. Recently, however, the Chargers have struck a deal with LT and now have both LT and Sproles in the bank. He has edited his post to

                                "This could easily become LB Rey Maualuga, especially since L.T. just signed."

                                So being that fact, it seems there is a potential major slide at RB like the WRs had last season. There may be none taken in the first round. If that is the case, and Knoshon Moreno doesn't go in the first, and Chris Wells doesn't go in the first, what happens to them then?

                                Well I for one have watched both of the backs throughout their last season campaigns, and still cannot see how some people believe Knowshon is better than Chris Wells. Everybody claims that Wells has trouble with injuries, yet it was basically a single injury in his entire 3 years as the Running Back for the Buckeyes. Yes he had some on and off trouble with his ankle after that point, but that is what happens to everyone in the NFL too. When you are mid-season, and you are hurt, you have to try to recouperate while at the same, when you are healthy enough to go on any particular week, you go. Sometimes that causes some setbacks, but when your team needs you to perform you have to.

                                Unlike the NFL where you can afford to have a couple losses, sometimes up to 8 in a really poor division (Chargers / Broncos / Arizona Cardinals), in NCAA football, a single loss can be the difference between being in the Big Game, and not being in the Big Game. So it makes sense that moreso than ever, you would not be able to sit on any given week because if your team loses because you didn't play, that's it. You just have to go out there, do your best, and hope it doesn't get aggrovated. Wells is healed up, showed amazing skill and ability in the combine and pro day, and is ready to roll.

                                Not to take away from Knowshon Moreno. For a guy to come into the Georgia starting lineup after red-shirting his freshman year, he performed outstandingly. 1336/1400 being his two seasons total rushing yards, while averagine a 5.4/5.6 respectively. 30 TDs in 2 years is amazing, and add to that two reception touchdowns in his senior '08 season, and he can play from the backfield as receiver too. 253/392 yard seasons in receptions with an avg of 12.7/11.9. Something to note...
                                Neither Running Back
                                81.82%
                                18
                                Moreno, and utilize split carries
                                9.09%
                                2
                                Wells, and utilize split carries
                                4.55%
                                1
                                Moreno as a pure backup
                                0.00%
                                0
                                Wells as a pure backup
                                4.55%
                                1
                                -03-15-2009, 07:22 AM
                              • steviej
                                Better R.b?
                                by steviej
                                Who would you rather have?
                                Marshal Faulk
                                28.57%
                                4
                                Steven Jackson
                                28.57%
                                4
                                Both
                                42.86%
                                6
                                -12-30-2005, 01:35 PM
                              Working...
                              X