Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Is the QB position the most important?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Is the QB position the most important?

    It seems to be an ongoing argument here at the clam....

    So I've decided to breakdown each division to identify which team has the more productive/talented QB. Then review which teams were playoff contenders and how the average to below average teams faired.

    Patriots -- Brady
    Jets -- Sanchez
    Dolphins -- Henne
    Bills -- ? Edwards
    -----------------------

    Bengals -- Palmer
    Ravens -- Flacco
    Steelers -- Big Ben
    Browns -- Quinn
    ----------------------

    Colts -- Manning
    Texans -- Schaub
    Titans -- Young
    Jaguars -- Garruard
    ----------------------

    Chargers -- Rivers
    Broncos -- Orton
    Chifs -- casell(sp)
    Raiders -- pick anyone
    ------------------------

    Cowboys -- Romo
    Eagles -- McNabb
    Giants -- Manning
    Redskins -- Campbell
    ------------------------

    Saints -- Brees
    Falcons -- Ryan
    Panthers -- Moore
    Bucaneers -- Freeman?
    -----------------------

    Vickings -- Favre
    Packers -- Rodgers
    Bears -- Cultler
    Lions -- Stafford
    ----------------------

    Cardinals -- Warner
    Whinners -- Smith
    Hawks -- Hasselbeck
    Rams -- Bulger
    ---------------------


    Playoff teams and QB

    Jets -- Sanchez
    Bengals -- Palmer
    Ravens -- Flacco
    Patriots -- Brady
    Colts -- Manning
    Chargers -- Rivers

    Eagles -- McNabb
    Cowboys -- Romo
    Packers -- Rodgers
    Cardinals -- Warner
    Vickings -- Favre
    Saints -- Brees

    Hate to say it folks but it seems the majority of times that the teams with the best QB in thier division make the playoffs.
    Last edited by Dominating D; -04-10-2010, 05:41 PM.

  • #2
    Re: Is the QB position the most important?

    you spelled Flacco's name wrong twice lol =P

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Is the QB position the most important?

      I'm not sure anyone is arguing it isn't the most important, but a lot of people either question Bradford's health, his ability to play in the NFL, or say we need to have more talent before we can have a QB. The last one is one I particularly disagree with and think in general is a poor team-building strategy to wait for your talent to build before you insert a QB.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Is the QB position the most important?

        Originally posted by berg8309 View Post
        I'm not sure anyone is arguing it isn't the most important, but a lot of people either question Bradford's health, his ability to play in the NFL, or say we need to have more talent before we can have a QB. The last one is one I particularly disagree with and think in general is a poor team-building strategy to wait for your talent to build before you insert a QB.
        Some feel that the QB postion is no more important than the DT position. I believe all are important but having a quality QB only helps a team perform at a high level. Sure you can argue by saying what about Dilfer. But Dilfer is the exception to the rule. For every Dilfer you will find you will find a P. Manning, T. Brady, and J. Ellway.

        Go Rams

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Is the QB position the most important?

          Originally posted by thickandthin View Post
          you spelled Flacco's name wrong twice lol =P
          Very surprise Flacco was the only one. Maybe I was thinking of the guy in the movie about the Skins Replacement players was it Falco?

          Go Rams
          Last edited by Dominating D; -04-10-2010, 05:42 PM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Is the QB position the most important?

            I dont doubt Bradford can play at the next level. And honestly i don't feel he is anymore likely to get injured than any other QB is. His shoulder was clean and overblown. Apparently it would have healed on its own but the surgery was done to save time and to prevent any recurring ill effects. With his added muscle to deal with anything nagging, and no history of chronic injuries or problems like bad knees or the like, I'm no longer concerned with his durability specifically. I just hope our bad luck with injuries has ended as a team.

            Bradford has all the skills and intangibles to succeed in the NFL. What the Rams give him to work with is going to be the deciding factor on if he will be the next big thing.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Is the QB position the most important?

              Originally posted by Dominating D View Post
              Very surprise Flacco was the only one. Maybe I was thinking of the guy in the movie about the Skins Replacement players was it Falco?

              Go Rams
              and you spelled Garrard Garruard lol but I'll stop being picky.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                Originally posted by Dominating D View Post
                Some feel that the QB postion is no more important than the DT position. I believe all are important but having a quality QB only helps a team perform at a high level. Sure you can argue by saying what about Dilfer. But Dilfer is the exception to the rule. For every Dilfer you will find you will find a P. Manning, T. Brady, and J. Ellway.

                Go Rams
                Every position is indeed important, but some more than others. QB is the most vital position on the offense, DT isn't even the most important position on the defense, at least in my opinion. I don't mean to insult anyone who thinks DT is as important as QB, but I seriously doubt you find a single person in the NFL who believes that, and for good reason, because it isn't true. I will take that back if someone can find me a source that says straight out "A DT is as important to any team as their QB".

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                  Originally posted by Dominating D View Post
                  Some feel that the QB postion is no more important than the DT position. I believe all are important but having a quality QB only helps a team perform at a high level. Sure you can argue by saying what about Dilfer. But Dilfer is the exception to the rule. For every Dilfer you will find you will find a P. Manning, T. Brady, and J. Ellway.

                  Go Rams
                  I agree. Same goes with McMahon and the Bears. A dominate defense like the Ravens and Bears are very rare. We are not even close to having such a defense, even if we do pick up Suh. What we need is a quarterback. A franchise QB to build this team around. Three of four first round picks have been devoted to defense by the Rams. Enough already.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                    Originally posted by berg8309 View Post
                    Every position is indeed important, but some more than others. QB is the most vital position on the offense, DT isn't even the most important position on the defense, at least in my opinion. I don't mean to insult anyone who thinks DT is as important as QB, but I seriously doubt you find a single person in the NFL who believes that, and for good reason, because it isn't true. I will take that back if someone can find me a source that says straight out "A DT is as important to any team as their QB".
                    Who said DT was more important than qb? I do disagree with you that DT is not the most important position on the defense. Pressure up the middle and occupying blockers is the most important thing and is what helps the defense succeed. Pressure up the middle gives the cb's less time to cover. Gives the qb less time to think. Occupying blockers frees up the linebackers to do there job which is penetrate and get to the ball carrier early and not have to be over run constantly by bigger o-lineman. I beleive on the defense it all starts up front with the d-line. Having a bad d-line and not pressuring the qb has been fatal for the Rams lately. How good do the Rams corners look when the qb has 8 seconds to throw the ball? So there is a need for a Suh like player on this team, however qb is just a bigger need. Hopefully Bradford is everything we need him to be.

                    I have come to accept the fact that the Rams are going to take Bradford. I don't see outstanding qb in him but the draft forces teams to takes qb's just because they need a supposed franchise guy. I hope I am wrong I just dont see franchise guy written on any of these guys. I take nothing from pro-days because even bad qb's like Ryan Leaf had amazing pro days. There have been good qb's who have had horrible pro days as well.

                    I hope Bradford turns out to be great because you really just dont know untill these guys hit the field. Not to mention our offensive talent isnt very good. I know everyone wants to pin it all on Bulger but the guy went from his best year to 3 of his worst years along with decaying talent. Bradford better be a Manning type qb's to elevate the play of the average o-line and average wr's. I realize the need for qb and have no doubt the Rams are picking Bradford, I just hope he's the guy they think he is and not just the best average qb of an average qb draft class. The draft is a mixed bag of success stories and complete fails when it comes to qb's in the first round.
                    Aim high Willis, Aim High!

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                      ofcourse it is hands down....lol and please dont mentin the ravens cuz that was pretty much the only team....recently ....

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                        Originally posted by ludairv View Post
                        ofcourse it is hands down....lol and please dont mentin the ravens cuz that was pretty much the only team....recently ....
                        On the contrary, there is every reason to mention the Ravens. The Ravens' Superbowl win exemplified the fact that football is a team sport.

                        Spagnuolo's mantra for our Rams is: Team first! .. I doubt future Hall of Fame quarterback Peyton Manning would have looked very good behind the Rams' 2009 O-line throwing to our group of no-name receivers ..

                        Asking which position is the most important on a football team, is sort of like asking which leg is most important to a dog chasing his tail ... Great teams have great players .. I think one can say there are "key" positions; for example most football pundits would agree that left tackle is a "key" position if a team has a right handed QB .. Point being: there are so many variables in the game of football it is an exercise in futility to say one player is more important than all his teammates.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                          Maui, when your trying to win a football game. You want the ball in the hands of a PEyton Manning, not a vince wilfork. You can afford to have a Leger Douzable playing DT, what you can't afford is having Ryan Leaf start for your football team. QB IS more important a position to have talent than Defensive Tackle, sorry. It IS a team sport and you need capable bodies at all position. But i don't see how you can say a Great QB isn't more valuable to a team given all his responsibilty than a DT, or using your logic, a Kicker. Every player contributes, but some contribute more than others. I want a right arm, but i can live without one, albeit it would suck. What i can't live without, is a brain.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                            Originally posted by Bralidore(RAMMODE) View Post
                            Maui, when your trying to win a football game. You want the ball in the hands of a PEyton Manning, not a vince wilfork. You can afford to have a Leger Douzable playing DT, what you can't afford is having Ryan Leaf start for your football team. QB IS more important a position to have talent than Defensive Tackle, sorry. It IS a team sport and you need capable bodies at all position. But i don't see how you can say a Great QB isn't more valuable to a team given all his responsibilty than a DT, or using your logic, a Kicker. Every player contributes, but some contribute more than others. I want a right arm, but i can live without one, albeit it would suck. What i can't live without, is a brain.
                            Disagree. You can only afford to have him if you have possession of the ball last. Otherwise your Manning clone's late-game heroics are for naught as your undertalented defense performs its best cheap hooker impression and lets the opponents score the winning points at will.

                            But then, I don't think Bradford's a great QB either.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: Is the QB position the most important?

                              Originally posted by PeoriaRam View Post
                              Disagree. You can only afford to have him if you have possession of the ball last. Otherwise your Manning clone's late-game heroics are for naught as your undertalented defense performs its best cheap hooker impression and lets the opponents score the winning points at will.

                              But then, I don't think Bradford's a great QB either.
                              I would take a good QB and Douzable at DT anyday over a bad QB and a good DT.

                              Not every position in football has the same importance and value. That's like saying a FB is as vital as a CB.

                              Comment

                              Related Topics

                              Collapse

                              • AvengerRam_old
                                *Final* AR Complete Round 1 Mock
                                by AvengerRam_old
                                This is my story, and I'm sticking to it!

                                1. Houston Texans: Reggie Bush, RB, USC
                                Don't be fooled by reports of negotiations with Mario Williams. He's just a pawn to get Bush's price down a bit. Bush is the "can't not take this guy" prospect in this draft.

                                2. New Orleans: Mario Williams, DE, NC State

                                Saints will get a guy who will be an impact rookie, and will a Pro Bowl selection within a few years. OTs in the NFC South will hate this pick.

                                3. Tennessee Titans: Vince Young, QB, Texas
                                For months, everyone has tried to find a reason to downgrade Young. The bottom line is, he's an exceptional performer on the football field, which is all that really should matter.

                                4. New York Jets: Vernon Davis, TE, Maryland
                                D'Brickashaw Ferguson would be the safer and, perhaps, the more logical choice, but the Jets are still a Broadway team, and Davis will make a lot more highlight film plays.

                                5. Green Bay Packers: A.J. Hawk, OLB, OhioState
                                With Williams gone, they will select the top remaining defensive player in the draft. Will be an instant impact player for the Packers.

                                6. San Francisco Niners: Michael Huff, DB, Texas
                                Niners will be a bit thrown by the selection of Davis at number 4, as he was likely their target. Huff will be touted as the next Ronnie Lott, though he's a different type of player.

                                7. Oakland Raiders: Matt Leinart, QB, USC
                                Leinart would have been the first pick in 2005, but he'll drop to number 7 in this draft. No problem – with his Hollywood image, he'll make up the money in endorsement contracts.

                                8. Buffalo Bills: D'Brickashaw Ferguson, OT, Virginia
                                Bills are surprised by Ferguson's fall, and will eagerly snatch him up. He'll start as a rookie, obviously.

                                9. Detroit Lions: Antonio Cromartie, DB, FSU
                                There always seem to be surprises coming out of Detroit, and this year is no exception. Cromartie's stock has been shooting up in recent weeks following his workout.

                                10. Arizona Cardinals: Jay Cutler, QB, Vanderbilt
                                Many teams (not the Rams, though) will try to trade up for Cutler but, in the end, he'll head to the Southwest to be Kurt Warner's short-term understudy.

                                11. St. Louis Rams: Haloti Ngata, DT, Oregon
                                Pickett, Lewis, Kennedy… will four times be the charm? Ram fans hope so, and Ngata is certainly a good prospect. Maybe the best prospect of the bunch.

                                12. Cleveland Browns: Brodrick Bunkley, DT, FSU
                                Fast rising Bunkley will be a welcome addition in Cleveland. They would have been happy with Ngata too.

                                13. Baltimore Ravens: Winston Justice, OT, USC
                                Will be a good RT initially, and will be the heir apparent to Jonathan Ogden, who is now 32. A good value pick.

                                14. Philadelphia Eagles: Chad Jackson, WR, Florida
                                While Eagles didn't miss TO's BS, they missed his...
                                -04-27-2006, 10:19 AM
                              • AvengerRam_old
                                2013 ClanRam Insiders 2 Round Mock Draft (Selection Thread)
                                by AvengerRam_old
                                Here we go!

                                Its time for the 2013 ClanRam Insiders 2 Round Mock Draft!

                                Here is your list of insiders and the official draft order:

                                shower beers
                                HUbison

                                AvengerRam

                                THOLTFAN81
                                Nick
                                laram0
                                sosa39rams
                                TekeRam

                                ROUND ONE
                                1. Kansas City Chiefs: Luke Joekel, OT, Texas A&M
                                2. Jacksonville Jaguars: Dion Jordan, OLB/DE, Oregon
                                3. Oakland Raiders: Sharrif Floyd, DT, Florida
                                4. Philadelphia Eagles: Dee Milliner, CB, Alabama
                                5. Detroit Lions: Eric Fisher, OT, Central Michigan
                                6. Cleveland Browns: Jarvis Jones, OLB, Georgia
                                7. Arizona Cardinals: Geno Smith, QB, West Virginia
                                8. Buffalo Bills: Cordarrelle Patterson, WR, Tennessee
                                9. New York Jets: Ezekiel Ansah, OLB/DE, BYU
                                10. Tennessee Titans: Jon Cooper, OG, North Carolina
                                11. San Diego Chargers: Lane Johnson, OT, Oklahoma
                                12. Miami Dolphins: Xavier Rhodes, CB, Florida State
                                13. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Sheldon Richardson, DT, Missouri
                                14. Carolina Panthers: Star Lotulelei, DT, Utah
                                15. New Orleans Saints: Barkevious Mingo, OLB, LSU
                                16. St. Louis Rams: Chance Warmack, OG, Alabama
                                17. Pittsburgh Steelers: Damontre Moore, OLB/DE, Texas A&M
                                18. Dallas Cowboys: Kenny Vacarro, S, Texas
                                19. New York Giants: Kevin Minter, MLB, LSU
                                20. Chicago Bears: Tavon Austin, WR, West Virginia
                                21. Cincinnati Bengals: Alec Ogletree, LB, Georgia
                                22. St. Louis Rams (f/WAS): Keenan Allen, WR, California
                                23. Minnesota Vikings: DeAndre Hopkins, WR, Clemson
                                24. Indianapolis Colts: Bjoern Werner, DE/OLB, Florida State
                                25. Minnesota Vikings (f/SEA): Jonathan Hankins, DT, Ohio State
                                26. Green Bay Packers: Alex Okafor, DE/OLB, Texas
                                27. Houston Texans: Terrance Williams, WR, Baylor
                                28. Denver Broncos: Datone Jones, DE, UCLA
                                29. New England Patriots: Desmond Trufant, CB, Washington
                                30. Atlanta Falcons: Tyler Eifert, TE, Notre Dame
                                31. San Francisco Niners: Jonathan Cyprien, S, Florida International
                                32. Baltimore Ravens: Manti Te'o, LB, Notre Dame

                                ROUND TWO
                                33. Jacksonville Jaguars: Johnthan Banks, CB, Mississippi State

                                34. San Francisco Niners: Jesse Williams, NT, Alabama (f/KC)
                                35. Philadelphia Eagles: Terron Armstead, OT, Arkansas-Pine Bluff
                                36. Detroit Lions: D.J. Fluker, OT, Alabama
                                37. Cincinnati Bengals (f/OAK): Matt Elam, SS, Florida
                                38. Arizona Cardinals: Menelik Watson, OT, Florida State
                                39. New York Jets: Larry Warford, OG, Kentucky
                                40. Tennessee Titans: Sam Montgomery, DE, LSU
                                41. Buffalo Bills: E.J. Manuel, QB, Florida State
                                42. Miami Dolphins: Justin Pugh, OG/T, Syracuse
                                43. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Zach Ertz, TE, Stanford
                                44. Carolina Panthers: Quinton Patton, WR, Louisiana Tech

                                45. San Diego
                                ...
                                -03-18-2013, 03:39 PM
                              • St.Louis Ram 56
                                Steven Jackson "bring It"
                                by St.Louis Ram 56
                                S T E V E N J A C K S O N BRING IT !!!!!

                                IS THIS WHAT YOUR ABOUT ?

                                YOU ARE SINGLE HANDEDLY EQUALIZING EVERYTHING THAT WAS PLANNED FOR , IN THIS PRE-SEASON. OVER GREED.

                                I BLAME THE COACHING STAFF THAT ARE EVEN ASSUMING THIS IS OK. LOMBARDI WOULDN'T EVEN LET YOU BACK IN CAMP. HALAS WOULD HAVE CUT YOU.

                                CALLING TO TEAM MATES TO SEE WHAT WAS COVERED /..LMAO.

                                LET ME CLUE YOU IN... YOU ARE ACCOUNTABLE TO YOUR FANS, AND RIGHT NOW, THIS FAN THINKS YOUR A PUTZ....YES A PUTZ..

                                ATTITUDE - CHARACTER - LEADERSHIP

                                WHICH OF THE TRAIT DO YOU EXIBIT HERE........YOU SAY NONE..

                                ME TOO..... AT LEAST WE AGREE.

                                IF YOUR NOT IN CAMP MONDAY PACK IT !

                                YOU HEAR LINEHAN !!!!! THIS SUX:ram:
                                -07-31-2008, 08:52 PM
                              • bigredman
                                Rams 2008 non-divisional opponents
                                by bigredman
                                HOME
                                Cowboys
                                Giants
                                Bills
                                Dolphins
                                Bears

                                AWAY
                                Eagles
                                Redskins
                                Patriots
                                Jets
                                Falcons
                                Fair...strength of schedule is balanced
                                82.35%
                                14
                                Not Fair...NFC East is NFL's strongest division
                                17.65%
                                3
                                -02-18-2008, 03:55 PM
                              • AvengerRam_old
                                The Flow Chart of Doom
                                by AvengerRam_old
                                It starts at the top...

                                THE OWNER
                                She's ill now, so obviously she
                                can't do anything to impact the
                                team's success. But even when
                                she was well, does anybody think
                                she added anything? Perhaps she
                                had a passion for the attention that
                                winning brings, but not for the
                                passion required to bring a winner.
                                |
                                |
                                THE FRONT OFFICE
                                Manned by individuals who know the
                                cost of everything, but the value of
                                nothing. Their talents are in business,
                                not football. Add a substantial helping
                                of ego, which has prevented them from
                                bringing in a true GM, and talent evaluation
                                has become a "blind squirrel" scenario. And
                                who's going to change this? Certainly not
                                the current owner.
                                |
                                |
                                THE COACHING STAFF
                                You get what you pay for. Pay for top notch
                                coaches, that's what you get. Hire from the
                                bargain rack, and sometimes you get lucky and
                                find a gem, but more often, you get what we have
                                now... a mess. The coaching staff is there to get
                                the most out of whatever talent is available. That
                                is not happening. And who's going to change this?
                                Certainly not the "bottom line first" front office.
                                |
                                |
                                THE TEAM
                                Talent levels in the NFL these days are fairly
                                close, even between the top and the bottom teams.
                                As a result, no team is ever too far away from rising
                                to the level of a playoff team. The Rams have been,
                                it seems close to that level for years. But who will get them
                                there? Certainly not the coaching staff, which lacks the
                                ability to maximize the talent we have. Certainly not
                                the front office, which knows money but not talent.
                                Certainly not the owner, who adds nothing to this team.

                                It all starts at the top for the Rams. Scott Linehan is a symptom of an overall problem that won't be corrected until the FLOW CHART OF DOOM is cut from the top. Get a new owner, hire a true football GM, bring in a new coaching staff, enhance the talent...

                                That, my friends, is the only formula that will bring sustained success.
                                -01-17-2008, 04:03 PM
                              Working...
                              X